These events are reported to us from
readers
from various stations and gathered from various news sources and public
information files. Comments are welcomed to correct or verify
information.
1985 - Fatality - Bob Tierney, Bakersfield,
CA. reportedly went back
into van to get fire extinguisher twice after placing mast into
power
lines.
(We are looking for more information
on this accident, as well as contact info for Bob's parents. We won't
forget
him, and by remembering him, we will improve the way safety is
addressed
in the broadcast industry.) [email
us with information about Bob Tierney]
1985 - Denver, CO operator
suffered two leg amputations and extended medical care. Went back into
van to lower
mast "because you can get in trouble for screwing up your truck."
1985 - Two Lexington KY
operators drive form live shot with mast
extended
turning truck on side, killing power in downtown Lexington.
1986 - Winston-Salem, NC
truck's poorly maintained old mast is
"launched,"
barely missing the operator when it fell. Op was taught to
watch
mast as it was elevating, and did, and also saw it fall to the ground
where
he was standing.
1986 - Louisville, KY operator
raises mast into powerline, breaker opens
before damage... operator drives away.
1986 - Burned hands, Cara
Crosby, WCAU, Philadelphia, PA. Mast was
raised into power lines.
1991 - (Oak Harbor,
Washington)--Some residents thought
they were under terrorist attack when the elevated antenna on a KIRO-TV
truck
snagged
a power line, setting off a small explosion and fire.
1993* - Top market op places
mast into power lines after driving off
with mast fully extended.
1993 - Lexington, KY truck/mast
damage in driveaway incident with mast
extended.
1994 - Fatality - "Al" Battle - Alexandria,
VA. Placed mast into 19,900
volts, rushed set up, pressure from assignment desk. Accident
videotaped.
1994 - Mast raised into 60kV
line. Fore Department warns Lexington,
KY operator.
1995* - Major market Chief
Photog in state he described as
"sleepwalking"
before incident drives away with mast extended, toppling mast.
Nobody hurt.
1995 - Fellow nicknamed
"Sparky" after his accident, placed mast into
power line and totaled truck (burned) and received permanent minor
injuries.
1995 - Double injury, WINK-TV
Ft. Myers, FL, news crew
severely injured and burned. One's injuries resulted in leg
amputation. The other, severely burned.
1995 - Fatality - WBGG-FM technician
Spencer Johnson killed when he
raises mast of remote studio van into power lines before concert at
bar.
1995 - Las Vegas ENG Op raises
mast into powerlines while performing
routine operational check in station parking lot.
1995 - Photographer drives in
field with mast fully extended trying
to find receiver.
1995* - Van in Chicago burns
after mast elevated into 50,000 volt
lines.
1995* - Numerous reports of
masts being brought into contact with
overhead
obstructions and breaking off mast top devices and damaging mast
structures.
1996 - WCSC technician, in his
first week of employment,
severely injured after he goes out with Chief Photog on live shot and
CP raises mast into
wires.
1996 - Engineering Supervisor
from WCAU-TV contacts this website author to ask where he can get
information regarding safety. His station pledged to have a safety
campaign in 1986 after
a mast/power line accident severely injured one of their employees, and
he was apparently unaware of this accident. The station apparently
forgot about it as well when they assigned him the task.
1996* - Las Vegas station
operator places mast into power lines in
station parking lot, was hurt.
1996* - Las Vegas van op is
reported to have driven down Las Vegas
Blvd. with mast fully extended and being broken upon contact with
traffic
light pole.
1997 - Fatality - Andrew Austin -
Greenville, MS. Used rubber strap
per station instructions to hold mast elevation lever as written in
OSHA
notes and final paper.
1997 - Serious burn injuries,
small amputations, 2 victims, Kimberly
Arms, Davis Bingham, Des Moines, IA. WOI-TV. Kim was severely affected,
in coma over a month, has undergone more than 20 surgeries since, more
treatment expected. Dave has reconstructed arm with limited use.
Further
future medical treatment anticipated for both. Had 7 words of warning
in
a company manual and undocumented hearsay training to educate them on
mast
safety. It was enough to hold up in court for reduction of fines and
free
up station from some "serious" citations.
1997 - Photographer from
Lexington, KY station drives with mast fully
extended into 7200 volt line. Mast ripped from truck.
1998* - Reports of masts being
"launched" as a result of over pressure,
improper maintenance, own seal rings and braces. Nothing new to mast
business,
but many more had been documented by others at the time this report was
submitted.
1998 - Beaumont, TX, KBMT ENG
truck grounds power line and cuts off
power to post office, hotel, restaurant and residences. Live shot never
aired.
1998* - Pittsburgh, PA. Truck
places mast up into centrally located
pole with power lines converging from 3 different directions.
1998* - WTAE, Pittsburgh. Mast
placed into power lines, reporter and
photographer brought to hospital. Reporter burned, operator monitored
for
shock.
1999 - Fatality - Geoff Fisher
- BCTV, British Columbia, Canada.
Sigalarm
equipped vehicle, Sigalarm out of service and on maintenance bench long
before incident. Fisher had passed maintenance department initiated and
administered safety test 9 months before.
1999 - Mast elevated into power
line at shopping mall while
manufacturer
is conducting tests on warning device. Minor injuries and slight damage
to van.
1999 - Fatality - Michelle
Lima, reporter for KSAT, San Antonio, TX, killed
crossing
street while packing up live shot. Crew parked across from power lines
to avoid that hazard. Station cited for not having written night time
work
procedures and not providing reflective vests to avoid the hazards of
darkness.
Station fined $3000. Check stub received from TX-OSHA through freedom
of information act materials stated: "Contribution."
2000 - Mast fall over damage.
WMUR ENG van driven in Concord, NH, with
mast elevated, hits traffic light pole and falls onto car. Driver not,
or just slightly injured. Approx $40K damage estimated. Not known if
driver
sued station after.
Story was front page newspaper news.
2000 - May 2nd - Alexandria,
VA. 3-Person crew - WTTG van mast
elevated
into 115,000 volt line. 2 injured, 1 very lucky after she hopped out of
truck after circuit breaker tripped, and right before it automatically
reset. OSHA citations, fines of about $8000 after
abatement.
Cameraman reportedly received 500 stitches in side of face after camera
he was holding, wired to truck, exploded.
May 22nd - Los Angeles, CA. 2-Person
crew - KABC van mast elevated into power lines, injuring 3, one
severely
resulting in amputations, extended treatment. CAL-OSH fines amounted to
close to $30,000. $25,000 for no training regarding overhead power
lines.
May 27th - Cedar Rapids, IA. 1-Person
crew - KGAN tech elevates mast into very apparent overhead power
lines
grounding 115,000 volts through his feet. Hospitalization and
amputations
of toes so far, and a "divot" taken out of his head according to one
report.
IOSHA (Iowa's OSHA) didn't bother to investigate it.
2000 - Van tipped over as its
driver reportedly ran a red light going
to a possible drowning story.
2000 - WGAL van reportedly
leaves school football game with antenna
elevated, crew and employees told to hush it up.
2001 - Fatality (2) NTSB report
states Ruben Rivero at fault for helicopter crash
which killed him and photog Rob Pierce after Rivero ascended so
abruptly
that the main rotor severed the tail of his craft. Rivero was heard to
have said "Watch this..." shortly before the accident.
2001 - Summer. WSB van doing
roadside live shot gets hit at high speed
by drunk driver while crew is set. Crew "tossed" 20 ft away.
2001 - Summer. Portland, OR
station crew saves another station's crew
person by pounding on van as mast is raised through lower lines and
towards
power lines.
2001 - September. KWCH van crew
escapes electrified van safely after
doing everything right. They stayed cool, called for help, got
it,
followed escape instructions.
2002 - Feb- From Electronic
Media: KTTV news van crashes in Los
Angeles: A Fox-owned, KTTV, Los Angeles, news van flipped over and
crashed
just outside Electronic Media's Los Angeles offices Friday around noon.
The truck was totaled as well as the equipment inside. [The
engineer] who operated the truck, was taken to nearby Cedars Sinai
Hospital,
where he is expected to be kept overnight for observations. [He]
had
indicated that the truck's brakes may not have been working correctly,
although the station said it regularly services the trucks. [KTTV
General
Manager] would not comment, except to say they are
investigating
the accident.
2002 - March - WAAY truck
trapped on railroad tracks long enough to
be hit by speeding train. Van damaged beyond repair. Crew handled
situation
well and escaped unharmed, and managed to get a lot of the equipment
out
of the vehicle before the hit.
2002 - Summer - Reports that 2
ENG truck ops are struck by lightning
in 2 separate incidents in Texas and Tennessee.
2002 - Summer - Report that
Albuquerque, NM operator drove vehicle
into power lines while moving van with mast extended. Operator had been
involved in a driving accident in an ENG truck earlier in the year.
Operator's
employment at station was reportedly terminated.
2002- August 5th - From a
market source.....Word is KECI-TV, Missoula, MT
wrecked
their sat truck, driving off with the dish still up & struck a
tree.
2002 - Summer - CTV British
Columbia had an ENG Traffic accident. It
involved one of their Microwave Trucks enroute to a live hit and two
street
racers speeding at a very high rate of speed. The speeding cars were
heading
towards the truck when one of them began to lose control of the car.
The
CTV driver went into avoidance mode and successfully avoided a head on
collision. Unfortunately, the avoidance maneuver did not take into
account
a light standard, and wham!
2003 - KNBC van burned when
covering California fires. Questions
regarding being too close to the coverage area too long remain.
2003- Fatality - CHIN Radio van
driver, one of the most experienced and
dependable, based on published reports, drives under an overpass with
mast extended. The mast, floor mounted behind the driver's seat, was
knocked off its mounting and into the driver's seat, pushing the seat
and driver through the windshield.
2003 - WEHT van backed up into
flooded area on side of road, and was
half-immersed into water. Reports stated van was a total loss.
2004 - January - Safety page
author at New Year's celebration. TV crew
has truck set up for live shot with mast extended through tree...Did
they look first??
2004 - Feb - WTVD-11-ABC truck
in Raleigh leaves scene with mast
apparently frozen up...hits wires, van tipped, operator fired.
Comments from B-Roll
online bulletin board: 1) I talked with the operator /
photographer. He says he was rushed to change locations, hit the "down"
switch. cleaned up his gear, jumped in the truck and took off. But the
mast had not come down, it was frozen up. He says he got no warning
alarms. When he exited the parking lot, he hit an overhead cable tv
line. The van basically did a wheelee then turned on its right
side. No serious injuries. 2) Someone
DID get hurt. According to newsblues, the reporter suffered some
cracked ribs. And the photog, LOST his job over it. I agree, WAKE UP
CALL!! To hell with the desk, no one should rush when it comes to
SAFELY running a livetruck. Whether his alarms were going off or not,
he should have VISUALLY confirmed that the mast was indeed down or not.
The blame falls no farther than the crew on scene. Lucky they weren't
high tension lines, or the job would have been the least of his
worries. 3) The most disturbing the to me is the photographer and
reporter heard no warning alarms. The truck is equipped with a mast-pin
interlock, an alarm should have sounded. That's why we have got to do
daily walk-around inspections, we've got to work as a team with the
reporters to make sure everything is set to go before we pull away. It
really does take only seconds to look up, look around, and save your
life. I know it's cliché, but safety IS a habit, and you've got
to take the time to complete a routine every time you take a truck out
of the parking lot.
2004 - Feb
- Sat truck
operator from WBNS-10-CBS involved in a serious accident on I-71
sending him to a local hospital with serious injuries.
From NewsBlues,
2-26-04 - Dispatch
Broadcasting officials will not discuss the particulars of the
accident, but insiders tell us [the operator] was talking on his
cell phone when he rear-ended a semi, then was struck from behind. The
crash blocked northbound lanes of the Interstate for several hours. The
satellite truck was destroyed.
2004 - Fatality - June 8 -
KBTX-TV
Photojournalist Matt Moore Killed in Accident. One report from the
scene said he was outside the truck, cops told him over loud speakers
not to move, he did, and apparently made contact with either the truck
or
nearby structure which was electrified.
2004 - Fatality - June 10 -
KETV
photographer Jeff Frolio, 45, was struck by a westbound car about 5
p.m. Thursday while crossing West Center Road near 222nd Street on
Omaha. He was taken by helicopter to Creighton University Medical
Center, where he died later that night. The Douglas County Sheriff's
Office is investigating the crash. Initial reports indicated that
speeding or alcohol were not factors. Investigators don't expect to
issue a citation.
The driver of the car in Thursday's accident, a 45-year-old Fremont
woman, told investigators that she didn't see Frolio until after the
accident.
2004 - The same WBNS operator
involved with the February Sat-truck accident was involved in another
accident, this time driving away with mast raised. He was reportedly
"looking for work" and in the midst of "personal problems" according to
one source.
2004 - (from email) KSBW
TV had a live truck "incident" in Gilroy. A news photographer with
three months experience and no live truck safety training drove away
from the live shot with the mast up. The mast contacted high voltage
wires, the cameraman and reporter luckily managed to escape the truck
without being electrocuted.
2004 - 8/30 from b-roll.net
(Same incident
as above?) One of our most reliable but new photogs accidentally drove
away with the mast up. He got about a 1/4 mile until he hit the power
lines, sending 40k volts through the truck before snapping off the
mast. the reporter suffered minor electrical burns on her hands and was
sent to the hospital. Engineering says the truck won't be
salvaged. This happened on a friday so he hasn't been dealt with
by management. Is definitely getting fired? Aren't there supposed to be
safety features to prevent this? Could that be his saving grace?
2004
- (From news reports.) 9-28 - A
reporter and two cameramen from WSNS-Channel 44 were involved in a
fatal collision in their news van. Cameraman Jorge Lara, who was
treated for minor injuries, was expected back after being out for a
week. Cameraman Carmen Capriola, who was driving the van and was more
seriously injured, was thoght to have injuries that would keep him out
longer. All three were heading south on Interstate 55 to Springfield to
cover the shooting of a guard in the Capitol Sept. 20 when a tire on
their van blew near Dwight, Ill. Capriola lost control of the 2002 Ford
van, which crossed the median and struck another vehicle, killing an
Oak Lawn minister, the Rev. Terry Allie, and his wife, Wendy Allie. The
van then struck another car, injuring the driver, Mohammad Ali of Villa
Park. The family of the minister filed suit in Chicago against
Telemundo Television Group, claiming its driver caused the fatal
accident. Investigators say the van driver lost control, crossed the
median and hit two cars, including the one driven by the Rev. Allie.
The lawsuit claims the driver, Carmen Capriola, was driving too fast
and didn't alert the Allies before driving into their vehicle.
Investigations are under way to determine the cause of the blowout. No
citations were issued at the time of the reports.
2005 - 1/4
- 10:15 PM Live truck's
mast snaps off....By: Capital News 9 web
staff...
An NBC affiliate in Syracuse made some news of its own.
That's after the mast of a WSTM live truck came
crashing down at a crime scene. Officials said the truck operator was
moving the vehicle with the mast fully extended in the air. It started
to wobble and the mast cracked off from the base, taking phone and
cable line with it.
No one was hurt, but some local cable customers were without service
for some time.
2005 - 2/21 Accident
involving ENG vehicle on I-90 in NY. Conflicting reports from two news
sources, one showing a picture of the tipped over van without noticable
damage to the rear. Readers can make their own conclusion from the
reports.
Report #1
Accident snarls traffic on I-90 - Updated: 2/21/2005 10:09 PM - By: Capital News 9 web staff.
.Slippery conditions are to blame for an
accident on I-90 that involved a Capital News 9 live truck, and backed
up traffic for quite a while Monday evening. Police said the
truck skidded down the exit five ramp and careened into the center
guardrail. The force of the impact caused the truck to turn onto its
passenger side. A Geo Metro sedan then ran into the back of the
van. The Capital News 9 driver was not seriously hurt. No tickets
were issued.
Report #2
Local news
operations are notorious for inaccurately reporting news involving
themselves.
According
to Capital News 9, slippery driving conditions in upstate New
York caused the station live truck to slide down an exit ramp on I-90
near Albany, whack the center guard rail, and flop onto its side. A Geo
Metro sedan, according to News 9, then ran into the back of the
van, snarling rush hour traffic. Three passengers in the car were taken
to Albany Medical Center and treated for minor cuts. The live
truck driver was not injured. No tickets were issued. But an
internal e-mail, obtained by NewsBlues, tells a different story,
claiming the live truck was actually merging onto I-90, when it was cut
off by a snow plow, causing the truck to whack the car on the passenger
side. According to the e-mail, from a sister station chief
photographer, the live truck rolled, and one of the passengers in the
car was in "serious" condition. Frankly, we don't know who to believe,
but a glimpse at the photo above shows the van is clearly NOT
on an exit ramp and has no discernable rear damage.
2005 - WXKR
Operator Shocked on the Job, story from WTVG -13 Toledo
VIDEO Intern shocked by high voltage
Sylvania Township Police and Fire say an intern with
WXKR was injured
while trying to do a live radio broadcast from Yark Automotive on the
Central strip. 18-year old Tyler Thomas was shocked when his radio
truck
became electrified by high voltage. It happened a little before 10
o'clock Saturday morning at Yark Subaru on the Central Avenue
Strip.
We're told the victim was with WXKR 94.5 and was setting up for a
routine live broadcast when the mast on the truck was raised and hit
electrical wires creating a life threatening situation. Thomas is
listed
in fair condition at Toledo Hospital.
Cumulus (WXXR's owner) Press Release
Toledo, OH The quick response of Sylvania
Firefighters and EMT units
aided a local WXKR Employee after receiving an accidental power line
shock during a live broadcast at 9:45am Saturday Morning. Tyler
Thomas,
the 18 year old WXKR radio Employee, was rushed to Toledo Hospital from
the Broadcast site at a Sylvania Yark Auto Dealership at 6019 West
Central Avenue.
According to Sylvania Township Fire Lt. Mike Ramm,
Mr. Thomas suffered
an electrical shock when he touched the station's truck, whose antenna
mast was touching a power line.
Sylvania Township officers Bill Tollison and Sgt.
Bob Hankenhof and
Firefighters Lt. Ralph Deshelter and Tom Smeed were acknowledged by
authorities at Toledo Hospital for their quick and efficient 911
response to the accident scene.
Mr. Thomas is recovering at Toledo Hospital and was
listed in fair
condition as of Sunday morning at 11:00 a.m.
In support of Tyler Thomas and his recovery,
employees of WXKR, Star 105
and Cumulus Media ask you to please keep him in your thoughts and
prayers.
2005 - (From NewsBlues,
3-28) KOMU-8-NBC in
Columbia, Mo., has one fewer news cruiser. Last week a young staffer
(who is also a university student) ran the truck off the road and down
an embankment near the airport. The unnamed driver was taken to a
hospital, but his injuries were not serious. We suspect he'll be
looking for another job soon.
2005 - (Emailed
from a wonderful safety friend.) Fri, 4/22/05, a (CBS) WDJT Ch 58
ENG truck leaving a live shot location atthe Waukesha Co courthouse
(WI) didn't lower the mast completely. I'm not sure if it was lowered
at all - but it was high enough to strike power lines that ran over the
road. This caused the mast to break near the top of the truck, and fall
off. I didn't hear of any injuries, but did hear that the
occupants of the truckdid get out rather quickly - luckily they weren't
energized on the way out. Two other notes; the 3 main news stations in
town are represented by a union, 58 had recently been involved in a
long fight to unionize, but did not. Also, the other 3 stations had all
held separate safety seminars withthe local power company, WE Energies,
in the past month (including a videoof yours). Unfortunately Ch 58 did
not hold any safety seminars that I know of.
2005 - From NewsBlues:
Wednesday, June 1, 2005. MAST FOXED UP Power crews worked through
the night and morning to restore electricity to 1,400 Indialantic
residents (east of Orlando) after a freelance engineer drove away from
the scene of a live shot with the microwave mast extended,snapping
three power poles.The accident involving the WOFL-35-Fox live
truck...the very same truck that collided with a turkey vulture (right)
last month.... occurred about 11:03 p.m. Tuesday.By noon Wednesday,
Florida Power & Light Co. had restored power to most area
residents. Those on the scene tell us the 30 foot mast is blackened and
snapped off near the base. We're also told that this is the
second live truck mishap for this particular freelancer, who recently
crashed into an entrance gate atthe station near Lake Mary."The driver
drove the truck and had the mast up for the live antenna," said Stan
Knott, general manager of the Fox O&O. "I doubt he intentionally
did it and I'm sure he feels bad about it. We're certainly sorry to see
anybody's power knocked out."
2005 - July 11th. Reports
of TV trucks having antennas damaged by Hurricane Dennis. One live
truck photographed on beach tipped over. Interesting intersection of
time as many trucks were deployed to Florida to make NASA mandated July
12th deadline to cover Space Shuttle launch on July 13, and may have
been assigned to "incidental" coverage in area strange to outsiders.
2005 - 8-3. From Denver
9News web site:
DOUGLAS
COUNTY - A team accustomed to
covering the news made news Wednesday afternoon, when their TV
microwave truck was involved in an accident on southbound I-25 at
Lincoln. The crew was headed to down
to the grassfire burning south of Castle Rock when the accident
happened. The top-heavy TV truck rolled over and collided with another
vehicle. The two people in the TV truck and the person in the other
vehicle were all taken to the hospital. Just
one lane of traffic was getting by after the accident causing a
backup
on I-25 southbound that stretched about four miles. The highway
was
cleared just after 4 p.m.
2006 - 1-28 - Radio station van
driven from event with mast extended, operator/driver ok, talent
injured. Small fire in van caused good reason to evacuate, and it was
during the evacuation that it was thought the injuries occured by not
clearing the van when hitting the ground. From the KSDK website: St. Louis radio personality Paul Arca was
injured Saturday afternoon when the KLOU-FM van he was riding in came
into contact with overhead power lines outside the Embassy Suites Hotel
in St. Charles. It happened after a remote broadcast from the Greater
St. Louis Golf Show at the St. Charles Convention Center after someone
failed to lower the broadcast mast on top of the van before driving
off. Sources tell NewsChannel 5 a 22-year-old woman who works in
promotions for parent company Clear Channel Communications was driving
the van. The van was destroyed by fire. Officials at St. Joseph Health
Center in St. Charles confirm 56-year-old Paul Arca was being
evaluated. Late Saturday, they said he was in good condition.
2006
- 4-8 (via email, verified:) For the record...there was an ENG accident
in Chicago last night. CLTV, Chicago's Tribune-owned 24-hour
cable news station, was covering the Chicago Cubs home opener.
The truck operator pulled away from the media parking lot with three
sections still up on his mast. He pulled down several wires,
stopped, and the stepped on the gas hard, snagging one thick wire,
sending the truck up on all but one tire. The truck miraculously
came back down on all four tires, snapping a pole and pulling even more
wires down. There aren't believed to be any injuries from this.
2006 -11-23 (from DCRTV.com).
No Injuries In 9 News Truck Mishap - 11/23 - DCRTV hears that a Channel
9/WUSA technican failed to lower the 65-foot microwave mast as he drove
away in a news remote truck. The mast hit the metal cross arm for a
pair
of traffic signals in Herndon Tuesday. The mast broke, but no one was
injured. Luckily, the mast didn't strike power lines, which could have
produced deadly consequences. The incident occurred at the intersection
of Ferndale Avenue and Herndon Parkway, at the site of a fatal
pedestrian hit-and-run, which 9 News was covering. Besides extensive
damage to the truck, the traffic signal pole and cross arm had to be
taken down and replaced by two temporary wooden poles with wire strung
between them to carry the traffic signals. Herndon expects to bill
Channel 9 for the repair work. According to a station source, several
safety features which might have prevented the mishap were not
installed
or activated on the truck. No word on any disciplinary action against
the WUSA employee.....